Kindle or Kindling?

My friend Brad over at IndyBookMan recently posted his misgivings about Kindle and the whole E-Book idea. I was about to leave a comment, but the more I thought about it, I realized that my thoughts would be too long for a comment. So here’s my hat being thrown into the ring:

In a nutshell, I don’t like it, I don’t want it. Kindle can bite my bytes.

When I’m sitting at my writing desk, surrounded by stacks and stacks of books, I can feel their presence — hear the whispers of hundreds of stories. They are my friends, my comrades, my muses. I could have all the “information” contained in those books in a little chuck of plastic and metal on my desk, but I would feel nothing from it. No matter what is stored in it, it’s still just a lifeless chunk of technology — without a soul. Books, actual books that I can feel and smell, have souls. Books that can rest on my chest as I fall asleep; books that I can read in the bath and drip water on their pages; books that I can shield the sun with as I lay on my back reading in the tall grass; books that I can underline, scribble in, dog-ear, press flowers in, tuck feathers in between pages that mention that bird, and throw across the room when they piss me off.

And every book on my shelf has a story to tell, beyond the story that’s printed on its pages. The story of where I got it. Some were gifts, some from trades with other writers, some found at quirky little book stores in towns I was passing through, some discovered at a Salvation Army hidden between romance novels and Christian self-help drek.

My most treasured came directly from the author and are inscribed personally. Jim Harrison wrote “to a fellow poet” and drew a one-eyed self-portrait; Peter Matthiessen honored me with “Namaste'” and “keep up your good work”; Bill Heyen said “prune for shade” and “let’s keep on keeping on despite the diminishments we feel”; Country Joe McDonald, John Sinclair and Ed Sanders all signed “with love” — Joe throwing in “peace” along with a peace sign; and Al Hellus, in the last thing he ever wrote to me, “friend and fellow traveler.” How could these fellow travelers and mentors sign their folder stored in my E-Book reader?

Which gets me to my biggest isssue with all of this. It seems to be just one more way to de-humanize and disembody the art of writing. To further remove the reader from the writer, so that the writer becomes a function of upload and the reader a function of download. That behind the beauty and wonder of the word is nothing more than strings of 1’s and 0’s, pulses of electricity on a curcuit board; rather than a living, struggling, dreaming and feeling person.

And when times are tough and it gets really cold here in this mountain cabin; a fire of these books would keep me warm and give me light to write by. No Kindle can do that.

About marcbeaudin

Poems, plays, books, roads, trails.
This entry was posted in Writing and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Kindle or Kindling?

  1. Sunshine says:

    One of the many reasons why I love you.

  2. Anonymous says:

    By the same token, a hand-written letter is more intimate than an email. Yet you do email, don’t you? The reason Kindling is a terrible idea is that it is a monopoly-in-the-making. This essay discusses why Kindle’s current business model is untenable and how it can evolve beyond an emblem for the trendy: http://incogrito.blogspot.com/2009/03/rekindling-reading.html

  3. Marc Beaudin says:

    Anonymous, are you the author of that article? It’s a good article, more technical than I’m able to really comment on, but it seems that the author shares my affinity (perhaps nostalgia) for a physical book.As far as letters, yes, they are more intimate than e-mail, which is exactly why I only use e-mail for “light” communication, but when I have important or intimate words to share, I use letters. In the same manner, the thoughts I post in blogs don’t carry as much weight (to me) as those I publish in my books.Thanks for commenting.

  4. Stenkle says:

    I think you're still allowed to buy paper books if you own a Kindle — although I haven't read the terms of service in detail.So if you want an autograph, why not buy that book as a paper book?

  5. Pingback: Ebooks of Vagabond Song Now Available | Marc Beaudin

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s